(727) 785-5100


How to Best Handle Shareholder Disputes

Written on February 28, 2020

The Florida Business Corporation Act allows direct actions by shareholders to enforce their rights against another shareholder, officer, director, or the company, but litigation isn’t always the best route. In fact, a lawsuit would typically be considered a last resort in all but the most egregious circumstances. It’s better to consider and implement other strategies to resolve disagreements, which can result in less disruption and more productive shareholder relationships going forward.

By working with a Clearwater, FL shareholder disputes attorney, you’re in a better position to efficiently, effectively handle shareholder disputes. Some options include:

Pinpoint Specific Areas of Disagreement:

Your first consideration should be working on an identified, defined point at the core of the shareholder dispute. Many disagreements are grounded in problems with communication, which can be often cleared up through pinpointing contested issues. If misunderstandings do run deeper, you’ll still achieve an accomplishment: You’re in a better position to move forward with other approaches to dealing with disputes.

Negotiations in Shareholder Disputes:

In the interest of maintaining relationships, it’s worth the effort to attempt to negotiate a workable solution to your disagreement. Still, all parties must be willing to compromise rather than attempt to enforce their strict legal rights. You should be prepared for some give and take in discussions, which you’re probably willing to do when you realize the alternative may be court action.

Consider Alternative Dispute Resolution:

There are two forms of alternative dispute resolution that may be effective in working out disagreements among shareholders:

  1. Mediation: Through this process, a neutral, trained mediator guides the parties through discussions that facilitate agreement. The expertise of the mediation professional focuses on defusing arguments, so the parties can have productive conversations toward compromise.
  2. Arbitration: This process typically involves a single arbitrator or a panel, who will hear evidence and arguments from both sides of a disagreement. It resembles a trial but is somewhat less formal, which is why it’s more cost-effective than litigation. Note that the findings of the arbitrator ARE binding on the parties – unlike mediation which has no legal effect if the parties cannot reach an agreement.

Review the Shareholders Agreement:

As you’re considering any of the above strategies for resolving disputes, keep in mind that the answer may be in your shareholders agreement – if you’ve executed one. These documents typically address how disputes can be resolved, such as calling a special meeting or voting on a resolution at the next general meeting. Some shareholders agreements will include a clause that requires mediation or arbitration before you can file a lawsuit in court.

Get Legal Help from a Clearwater, FL Business Law Attorney

When you have assistance from a knowledgeable shareholder disputes lawyer, you may be able to avoid costly, disruptive litigation that puts your business at risk. These are just a few options to consider, but there may be other strategies depending on your circumstances. For more information on how we can help, please contact Clearwater Business Law at (727) 785-5100 to set up a consultation. Our team serves the needs of businesses throughout Pinellas County and the surrounding region, so we’re happy to help.


I strongly endorse Andrew Mongelluzzi. He is a very skilled and able business attorney focused on customer service and results. On the front end, Andrew deftly advises new businesses on organizing properly, acquiring necessary licenses, contracting with vendors & customers, and dealing with various compliance issues that may arise. On the back end when things go south, Andrew counsels and navigates businesses through complex commercial disputes and aggressively represents them in negotiations, mediation, arbitration, and in litigation so that businesses can legally move on and get back to business. Andrew’s ability to identify legal issues and approaches to resolve business-related issues is a strength that I have learned from and professionally relied upon in approaching the business matters and cases that I handle. I regularly refer business to Andrew knowing that he will diligently represent his business clients and their best interests.
Relationship: worked together on matter

- Frank N. Genco, Florida Bar No. 440086

Attorney Mongelluzzi and his team provided excellent and quality service. I always felt that my needs were met and that the firm was invested in me and my case. The quality services I received at Mongelluzzi’s firm were remarkable. From the initial meeting they were responsive to my calls, questions and concerns. All issues were handled professionally and timely, easily accessible, got back to me quickly, aggressive and got me the results that I wanted. Attorney Mongelluzzi and his staff all gave my case their personal attention and provided the quality of work that anyone would want when hiring an attorney.

- Client

Andrew is very thorough defining the outcome expectations. In my case, it was setting up a new corporate entity. He advised me on the most beneficial option and he then executed on that path. Andrew is a very pleasant person to work with. He is determined, skilled and committed to his client’s success.

- Gil Pinney

Andrew helped me through a difficult situation with American Express and we won the case. A great job by Andrew! He also helped me with T&C’s in my company. I would recommend Andrew highly as an attorney.

- John Sams

As a business owner for 12 years I have seen my fair share of ups and downs. Some of the downs would include landlord/tenant disputes and creditors that may have not been fulfilled to agreement. Andrew has met both of these situations for me in a timely, positive, and affordable manner.

- Rich Mattes

It was very nice to have a lawyer who not only is fierce in negotiations but has been successful in business. This is a lethal combination. I was glad he was on my side.

- Nigel Castanheiro

Andrew helped me with a contract litigation case. The lawyers battled it out for over a year and we finally got a reasonable settlement offer. Then the other side tried to back out. Andrew figured out how to force the other side to honor the deal and really knows his way around the court system. Definitely feel comfortable using him again.

- John Ellis


  • *Contacting Clearwater Business Law or any individual at the firm through this form does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Any time-sensitive or confidential information pertaining to your case should NOT be sent through this form. Thank you.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.